Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Question of the Day

I just read on Perez Hilton that Life & Style Mag is giving a few spoilers, it was nothing that we haven't already heard except this:

"Additionally, in the book Edward says he will turn Bella into a vampire only if they marry. In the movie, however, he offers a different ultimatum."

So my question is this:
Do you think this is true? What would a different ultimatum be? Do you think removing the marriage aspect will change the heart of the story?

10 enjoyed the bouquet.:

Peacey said...

If they did I'm going to be majorly ticked.

Erin said...

Huh. I've heard rumors from my students that they are only making three movies, so maybe the ultimatum is that she goes to college or something? And they cut out Breaking Dawn completely?

I'd be sad they change stuff, but I might be OK with that...

Although a sick part of me really wants to see how they portray Renesmee on the big screen.

alison said...

I think it would add more drama if Edward asked her to stay away from Jacob if she wants to be married. It would add to the drama and the hatefest and whatnot. but really I have no idea.

alison said...

oops. I read that wrong. Still, he could say he would only turn her if she stayed away from Jakie.

Ryah said...

Erin, I heard that Robert is all set to do BD, but they can't find time to shoot cause he's so busy.

Hmmm, I don't think not having the marriage aspect would change the story, but I do wonder what the new ultimatum would be.

Kari said...

Ohhh, this is a good bit of gossip. I like Alison's idea -- I think it will tick off a whole slew of fans. Not me though, I like it. Bring on the drams.

Ginger said...

Yes, I like Alison's theory... staying away from Jacob.

I heard the other day that they ARE making Breaking Dawn. This upsets me a little. I think they need to stop at Eclipse.

Jes said...

Yes, they ARE doing BD. Ron confirmed it at Cannes...

♦Z~Z♦ said...

I don't think they'd change it. I mean, what else would make Bella wait for a whole other book to take place. Of course the whole Jake thing is possible, but I don't think they're that mean... and if they are I hate them.

In an above comment someone said that Rob if all ready to do BD, and I can only think of a few scenes that stick out from their... differentness, and I'm a little worried about him.

Kaitlyn said...

how in the world are they going to do BD, anyway?
It would be interesting to find out about the new ultimatum