Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Question of the Day

Were there any characters you didn't like from the Twilight Series? If so, did Breaking Dawn change your mind or further solidify your assessment?

10 enjoyed the bouquet.:

heatheryruth said...

For the first three books I REALLY disliked Jacob! (I know those that are Jacob lovers I'm sure you are wanting to kick me out!) I felt he was an immature nuisance that just kept interrupting Bella and Edward's relationship! I Thought his tactics we're immature and he just BOTHERED me.

However in Breaking Dawn both prior to and after he imprinted I felt he changed! He did the right thing by defending the Cullens and then again redeemed himself by continuing to stand up for them all the way to the end! I think finding his "meaning for life" in Renesmee helped him mature and that made his so much more likable to me! If SM DOES a storyline in the future about Jacob and Nessie I can gladly say that I look forward to that story!

Kari said...

I agree with you. Jacob really bothered me in Eclipse. He redeemed himself in BD with his sarcasm and standing up for the Cullens.

I like Aro a little better. I still pretty much hate Caius. I thought we would have heard more from him but he was still as silent and lame in BD as in Eclipse.

I still love Karen Newton, despite the fact that she's not in the last book.

Corinne said...

Wow, Kari. That's funny because I was just going to say that I HATE Karen Newton. She brings nothing to the table and, if anything, her fashion sense brings everyone down.

I also was never that big of a Sam fan. He always seemed kind of "fake nice." He really didn't do anything for me in BD either. Except make me ponder if I, too, wanted Bella dead. (I'm glad she survived, she was way better as a vamp).

Maggie said...

Well, I never really liked Rosalie. She was pretty bitchy all three books, even in Eclipse when she opened up to Bella. I felt like she was just condescending as if she knew what Bella wanted more than Bella did herself. In BD, I hated her even more for using Bella to get a baby. I am glad she supported Bella in the end, however, she just really only cares about herself. So BD really just made me continue to dislike her.

I posted on the Facebook group under question of the day suggestions if anyone wants to post it!! :)

Kari said...

Yay! It's a good one too. I'll post it tomorrow. Thanks!

Maggie said...

Thanks Kari!! I've been trying to think of a good question for BD haha.

Erin said...

Yay Maggie! That's awesome!!!

And to answer the QOD today...hmmm...I have to go with Rosalie, too, I think. Although once Eclipse explained why she was so bitchy to Bella, I still can't get myself to like her.

And I want to slap Jane upside her bratty head. But I also kind of want her power...

Jill Berry said...

This is a boring answer, but I don't think there were any characters I didn't like! If I had to choose I'd say Leah...her story just didn't capture or interest me I guess.

Jes said...

It is no secret that Jacob always bothered me, BUT I really did enjoy him in BD.

Also- Esme bothers me, I don't have any reason why though... And then I just thought is was weird that she had like two speaking lines in BD

Anonymous said...

I don't like *Rose. I started to warm up to her when she explained herself, but BD really didn't help her picture.

Sam was a very confusing caracter. The whole beggining of NM you learn to hate him, then all of a sudden, he's the good guy. he sort of stays a good guy until BD then he's a bad guy again. by the end of things, everythings all cleared up but still, very confusing.

I'm going to go read the next post so I don't sit here all morning.

*I don't want to type her full name when you know who I'm talking about